People always search for the number one mascara. The mascara that is suitable for your eyes and provides your desired appearance is the number one mascara for you. Additionally, it enhances your natural eyelashes appearance and provides you with the desired look that you want. For instance, you will choose the lengthening and volumizing mascara if you want more volumizing and fuller lashes. If it works well for you, this is your number one mascara. But if your mascara does not provide you with the desired volume and appearance, then it is not number one for you. Moreover, It makes no difference whatever brand of mascara you have bought.

On the other hand, if you want to achieve a bold look and dramatic eyelashes. You will select the mascara with special features that hold the curl and thicken the eyelashes. Suppose you bought the $50 mascara to achieve the bold eye appearance; unfortunately, it did not work. In this case, you will not think you have wasted $50 on a mascara. After spending even $50 on luxury mascara, you will think about the desired appearance you have yet to achieve. In comparison to $50 mascara, suppose you have achieved your desired appearance with $7.98 mascara, which also suits your eyelashes’ needs. So, this cheap $7.98 mascara is your number one mascara.

The Best Mascaras to consider For your Eyelashes

Every girl and woman loves mascara because it makes the eyes pop and enhances the look of your eyes with more open and noticeable eye effects. In this article, I have selected the top mascaras for different types of eyelashes. All the mascaras listed below are smudge-free and have volumizing thickening, and lengthening features. Some mascaras are best to hold the curl with other features like fuller lashes and a bold appearance.

You will be pleased to know I have also included the original reviews from verified customers on prominent websites like Amazon, Byrdie, and Walmart. These reviews will help you in decision-making. Let’s dig in and choose the number one mascara according to your lashes and desired appearance. The mascara that makes your eyes attractive and enhances the appearance of the eyelashes is the number one mascara for you.

No.1 Waterproof: Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara

Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara - Cosmetics Gears

Overall Ratings 4.4 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$8.90 at amazon, $12.99 at covergirl, $9.37 at Walmart, $12.99 at Ulta.

Pros:

  • The micro bristles are good enough to reach each lash and coat it from root to tip. Even they are good for wiping off messy mascara from your eyelids, or if you have applied excess product, You can wipe off it easily.
  • Another customer rated it five stars and said she has dry eyes constantly tearing up. On her tearing-up eyes, this mascara stays on all day. Moreover, she suggested that it is truly waterproof and tear-proof mascara and best for those who have watery eyes or live in humid weather.

Cons:

  • It is cruelty-free but unsuitable for highly sensitive eyes or people with skin allergies and eczema.

Overview

It is a very smooth application and doesn’t get chunky. Moreover, it stays on despite water. Covergirl Lash Blast is available in four colors, so it is best to wear Covergirl Lash Blast when going to parties or weddings. Moreover, it has no clumps or flaking and adds ten times more volume to the upper and bottom eyelashes.

A customer rated this mascara five stars and said it can survive your boyfriend’s air. Moreover, she said it lasts against the powerful waves of the beach while swimming or during the shower. It stays on your eyelashes and does not smudge. She even slept with it for three days to test its long-lasting, and she was amazed to see that it was in place and did not move or transfer. At the end of her review, she recommends elf makeup remover balm to wipe off it.

No.1 for Dramatic Lashes: Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara cosmetics gears

Overall Ratings 4.4 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$24.00 at Amazon, $29 at toofaced, $29 at Sephora, $29 at Ulta, $16 at Target but no free delivery.

Pros:

  • Lengthens and curls the eyelashes.
  • Voluptuous volume.
  • Locks curl into place.
  • To maximize the volume, apply second coat.
  • Hourglass shaped brush for dramatic and voluptuous volume.
  • Lengthens and curls the eyelashes with just one coat.
  • Buildable formula.
  • Clump-free Volume.

Cons:

  • Dries quickly.
  • May smudge after couple of hours. Waterproof version of this mascara is awesome for all day wear.

Overview

Too Faced’s Better than Sex Mascara is a popular product that works well for all short lashes, especially those with short lashes. The buildable and volumizing formula is designed to make lashes darker, fuller, and more defined. It contains film-forming polymers, which create and set a curl in the lashes, and Acacia Senegal tree oil, which adds volume. A combination of peptides makes it easy to condition lashes with every coat.

This mascara is unique in its formula, and its packaging adds to its charm. This mascara looks excellent in a luxurious baby pink bottle with a large, flat brush. The hourglass brush separates, curls and coats individual lashes, making them look more perfect. Let the formula dry slightly before you apply more coats to avoid clumping. For the best results, use this mascara with your favorite setting spray.

No.1 Clean Mascara: ILIA – Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara

ILIA - Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara

Overall Ratings 4.4 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish: $28 on Amazon.

Pros:

  • Non toxic and cruelty-free.
  • Friendly with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • Derived from natural ingredients 99%.
  • Very lightweight formula.

Cons:

  • Quick dry formula: If you want fuller lashes, apply four to five coats with a delay of two or three seconds.

Overview

Ilia, a clean beauty brand, has created a water-resistant mascara that is waterproof and waterproof. It contains keratin and shea butter, and beeswax to condition, nourish, and fortify lashes. The mascara also holds curls and lifts them. The formula is safe for sensitive eyes and features a dual-sided brush that separates each lash. The formula is cruelty-free and gluten-free and can be washed with warm water. Ilia is a trusted brand by many Hollywood makeup artists, such as Nathalie Eleni (client: Anya Taylor), who have worked with Amber Heard.

It is a gift for people who are Contact Lens Wearers, a very safe product. Contact Lens Wearers can use it without any precaution because ILIA declared they used 99% natural ingredients in mascara. Additionally, Limitless lash lengthening mascara is tested by Ophthalmologists, and they claim it is the safe mascara for sensitive eyes. So, contact lens wearers and people with sensitive eyes can use this product without hesitation.

No.1 Drugstore: Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara

Overall Ratings 4.5 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$9.98 at Amazon, $12.99 at Ulta, $12.99 at Maybelline.

Pros:

  • Volumizing the lashes
  • Holds the curl and long-lasting
  • Natural lengthening
  • Also suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • The bamboo extract and fibers in this volumizing waterproof mascara give eyelashes a long-lasting and thick effect. It is also very lightweight, so you won’t feel the product on your eyelashes.

Cons:

  • Three percent of customers on Amazon gave two-star ratings and said they did not get the hype as per the advertisement.

Overview

Maybelline Sky High Waterproof Mascara will be your new best friend if you want to lift and define your lashes. Plus, it is ophthalmologist-tested, suitable for sensitive eyes, and the waterproof formula is easily removable with waterproof eye makeup remover.

Sky High waterproof mascara for swimming features with unique Flex Tower mascara brush. You can get your desired volume with just one coat. It coats each lash from root to tip and separates them to give you dramatic lashes. An allergist and an ophthalmologist approve this mascara. It is ideal for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

No.1 Long-Lasting: Christian Dior Diorshow Waterproof Mascara

Christian-Dior-Makeup-Diorshow-Mascara-Waterproof-Mascara

Overall Ratings 4.3 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$31.97 at Amazon, $32 at Dior, $32 at Ulta, $32 at nordstrom, $32 at Sephora.

Pros:

  • Long-lasting waterproof effect.
  • Easy to curl your eyelashes with curved XXL brush.
  • Glamorous look and Dramatic volume.

Cons:

  • Some customers said they received the little product in a container.

Overview

It comes in three exquisite colors: maroon, blue, and black 090. These colors are very rich; they will make your eyes pop without being clownish. You will notice the blue color is rich, and no one will stop to comment on your picture. It is effortless to remove with any makeup remover. Your eyelashes will not look chunky and gloopy; accept my word.

Lift Model ExtrmeTM ingredients and latex polymers are present in this mascara, which is lightweight and does not feel heavy. This iconic best mascara gives a new, defined look to older women’s eyelashes with a richer, deeper color. It provides the most eye-opening look for up to 24 hours, the most potent long-wearing formula. Best in all, it gives your eyes a mesmerizing appearance.

No.1 Editor’s Choice: Lancôme Lash Idôle Lash Lifting & Volumizing Mascara

Lancôme Lash Idôle Lash Lifting & Volumizing Mascara cosmetics gears

Overall Ratings 4.5 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish: $25.50 on Amazon.

Pros:

  • White Tea extract that conditions the eyelashes and provides feathery finish.
  • So easy to apply the application and no smudges on eyes.
  • The wand is curved and perfect for building the volume for a defined look.

Cons:

  • The top critical review by a customer on Amazon is she said it doesn’t give the thickness & big lashes.

Overview

The Lash Idole Mascara is a fantastic choice for thinning lashes and will assist you in getting beautiful lashes. Each lash quickly multiplies and thickens thanks to the ground-breaking, zero-clump formula. Additionally, it multiplies, curls, and stretches even the shortest lashes. This volume mascara increases the volume of your lashes for a larger look thanks to its 360 microdots.

You know your eyelashes can be essential if you have sensitive eyes. You could have redness, irritation, or other issues if you don’t care for them. This is why you must ensure you’re using the right type of makeup.

No.1 for False Lashes Effects: Maybelline Falsies Push Up Drama Waterproof Mascara

Maybelline The Falsies Push Up Drama Waterproof Mascara cosmetics gears

Overall Ratings 4.4 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$20.40 at amazon, $11.99 at Maybelline, $12.99 at Walmart.

Pros:

  • A customer reviewed and said, first curl your eyelashes with an eyelash curler, then apply a single coat of this mascara and build it. Add a second coat to volumize and false eyelash effects to add drama. Moreover, she wrote that this mascara can create a mess if you have naturally long eyelashes and wear glasses. Because it is waterproof, it will make your eyelashes hard and touch your glasses repeatedly while blinking your eyes. It would be best to use contact lenses with this, or Maybelline Volum’ Express Mega Plush Waterproof mascara is good to use with glasses; it will provide you soft, feathery finish.

Cons:

  • It is not for those who want natural eyelashes because it adds the full drama.

Overview

One of my (Alezy) favorite mascaras. From Maybelline, and it is falsies push-up mascara. This one goes on easy every time. The magic is that it does not clump and gives your lash a more volumized look with perfect length. It includes rice bran wax to optimize lash volume, making it flexible. Push up cup brush with cup-shaped bristles, and separate and lift lashes. The new creamy plumping formula delivers instant volume and holds the curl.

No.1 in Lightweight: NARS Climax Mascara

NARS Climax Mascara cosmetics gears

Overall Ratings 4.4 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish: $18.95 on Amazon.

Pros:

  • Adds length and leaves the lashes healthy.
  • A very lightweight formula that will not clump or smudge.
  • Buildable volume.
  • Soft feathery finish.

Cons:

  • It is not suitable for sensitive eyes.

Overview

Anyone having straight eyelashes will receive outstanding lash volume and long-lasting curl from this mascara. You won’t be let down if you prime. Just keep that in mind; discover the ideal mascara! My straight, long, delicate lashes need a lash curler, but it works GREAT on them. This mascara has perfect weight—not it’s too wet. Innovative mascara provides deep black color and buildable volume in a thin, flexible consistency that won’t clump or smudge.

What You Should Know Further: With the help of the Lash Moisture Complex, lashes are lifted and thickened in a whipped, creamy texture that never feels heavy or stiff. Ribbed bristles on the unique, full-bodied brush catch and coat each lash for a potent effect. Lashes are wrapped in blackened pigments for powerful dimension and rich color.

No.1 Volumizing: L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Waterproof Mascara

LOreal-Paris-Makeup-Voluminous-Original-Volume-Building-Waterproof-Mascara-cosmetics-gears

Overall Ratings 4.2 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$7.69 at Amazon, $10.99 at Ulta, $8.98 at Walmart, $9.99 at lorealparisusa, $8.99 at Target, $11.49 at Walgreens.

Pros:

  • Suitable mascara for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • Fragrance-free
  • Very good if you want a bold look
  • Separates and coat each lash and provide buildable volume.

Cons:

  • The manufacturer changed the wand design, and it is a top critical review on Amazon by a customer. She is requesting the L’Oréal to change back the wand, please. It shows she is a regular customer of this L’Oréal mascara.

Overview

L’Oréal Paris Original Volume Building Waterproof Mascara is formulated with a unique waterproof formula that contains intense black pigments that thicken and lengthen the lash. This mascara is designed to build and separate your lashes to four times their standard thickness! It is also easy to wash off using a suitable waterproof makeup remover. It can be used on sensitive eyes and is the best waterproof mascara for people who wear contact lenses.

Suppose you are looking for something long-lasting and black that would make your lashes longer if they are short and hard to grow out of. You will get all of that in this mascara. The color (Carbon Black) is lovely, just what you want. A nice dark black color defines lashes in a naturally dramatic look. It stays on well throughout the day; no smudges, don’t feel wet either. No crumbles. You will love L’Oréal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Waterproof Mascara. I highly recommend it to those girls who don’t want to wash their eyes and want to see their eyes in a sexy look for a long time.

No.1 for Intense Length: L’Oréal Lash Paradise Mascara

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Makeup Lash Paradise Mascara cosmetics gears

Overall Ratings 4.4 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$7.33 to $9.49 at Amazon, $11.99 at lorealparisusa.

Pros:

  • Voluptuous volume and intense length.
  • Feathery soft lashes.
  • Non-Clumping.
  • Non-Flaking & Smudge-Proof.
  • Feathery Soft Full Lashes.

Cons:

  • The top critical review by a customer on Amazon is that after using it for a couple of weeks, it got very clumpy in the container. In my opinion (Alezy thoughts, review writer, and makeup artist), she did not cap the mascara tight after use, and it went dry in the container.

Overview

The Cuban-born American singer and songwriter Karla Camila Cabello Estrabao, famous as Camila Cabello, also used this L’Oréal lash paradise mascara and reviewed it in the Vogue video. In this video, she tells about all the makeup products she uses daily. Camila Cabello said she had been using this mascara since she was not famous, and L’Oréal Lash Paradise is her favorite mascara.

L’Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara Review, Ratings And Buying Guide – 2023 Updated, read full review.

NO.1 for Older Women: Primelash Mascara

Prime Prometics Prime Lash Mascara Price with Pros and Cons

Overall Ratings 4.7 out of 5 Stars:

Price at time of publish$28 on Amazon, $28 on primeprometics.com.

Pros:

  • Game changer for thin short lashes.
  • Darker and longer eyelashes in just one coat.
  • It is cruelty-free and hypoallergenic mascara, best for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • The magic wand provides the smooth application and doesn’t clump.
  • Lengthens lashes beautifully.
  • Vegan and Cruelty-free.
  • Easy to remove with soap or just water.

Cons:

  • It may comes off in humid weather.

Overview

A reviewer named Michelle S.” wrote about this mascara on Amazon. She said she has thin and short eyelashes; this mascara is a game changer for her eyes look now. She specifically bought this mascara after watching ads on YouTube or television. With just one coat, she noticed that the lashes looked feathery, lengthened, and fuller. After the first coat, she waited to see the lashes behavior, whether they shrank back or not. She noticed that it lengthened the lashes, and they did not shrink back after drying the mascara.

After drying the mascara, she applied a second coat and experienced that her lashes looked feathery again and thicker without stick-looking lashes. Primelash mascara is the Holy Grail for her, and she will continue to buy it. Continue reading to discover more reviews for prime lash mascara.