Primelash mascara VS. Thrive mascara – The Key Differences

PrimeLash Mascara is designed specifically for mature, thin, sparse lashes, and bare eyes, featuring a hypoallergenic and pH-balanced formula suitable for sensitive eyes. It’s vegan and cruelty-free, with credentials that support ethical beauty standards, while its lightweight texture prevents clumping or flaking for easy application. In contrast, Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara is notable for its fiber-infused tubing formula, which is designed to significantly lengthen lashes. Its patented blend of orchid stem cell complex, Japanese pepper extract, shea butter, and castor seed oil aims to condition and improve lash health. Unlike PrimeLash, Thrive’s mascara is also free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates, appealing to those seeking clean beauty options.

In summary, for individuals with sensitive eyes or who prioritize ethical beauty standards, PrimeLash mascara is an ideal choice. For those seeking dramatic lash length or a formula free of common additives like parabens, Thrive Causemetics mascara offers a compelling alternative.

Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’ve personally researched, tested, and truly believe will add value. Learn more.

Primelash Mascara vs Thrive Mascara — Which One’s Better for You?

If you’ve been searching for a mascara that truly delivers—no clumps, no flakes, and no irritation—you’ve likely seen Primelash and Thrive Causemetics. Both are popular with women who want softer, lifted, natural-looking lashes, but each meets slightly different needs. Read on to find out which is best for you! 👇

Quick Comparison Chart

More Volumizing Primelash mascara $28	More Lengthening Thrive liquid lash mascara $26

Formula & Application

Primelash Mascara has a creamy texture that glides on, adding gentle volume and separation for fine or thinning lashes. It never feels heavy or stiff, and the curved brush easily coats every lash.

Thrive Mascara feels light and gives a false-lash look. Its tubing formula coats each lash for length and definition. The result is bolder and more dramatic than Primelash.

Primelash mascara before and after results

Primelash Users Say

Annelise R primelash user says on primeprometics official website, “PrimeLash really impressed me. It goes on easily, and you can build it up for more volume. The fiber extensions make my lashes look fuller, and the wand helps separate them for a nice, fanned-out look. I also appreciate how easily it washes off. I don’t have to worry about smudging or mascara running when I work out, but it still comes off easily with water and gentle soap. Additionally, there are numerous color options available. PrimeLash has definitely improved my lash routine.”

Teresa P says on primeprometics official website, “This mascara really surprise me. It made my lashes look just like I was wearing falsies, and it came off easily at the end of the day. I’ll be buying it again for sure.”

Marcia H shared on the Prime Prometics website that she has a lot of stick-straight lashes, and this mascara works perfectly for her. She usually avoids buying products advertised online, but she’s happy she made this purchase. The mascara doesn’t clump and defines every lash. Although she’s 72, her lashes keep falling out and growing back, so they aren’t old, but they have lost their original color. She says this mascara truly delivers.

“I am 76 and have never used a better-performing mascara,” shared Lynda W on the Prime Prometics website. One swipe gives a light, feathery look. It dries fast, so you can add more layers for a bolder effect. Taking it off is incredibly easy. I’ll definitely buy more when I need it!

Hayley W says on primeprometics official website, I love this mascara. It defines and lengthens my lashes, stays put all day, and never smudges. The nourishing ingredients are a great bonus and have helped my lashes feel stronger. Thanks, Prime Prometics!

Thrive mascara before and after results

Thrive Fans Say

Cynthia W shared on the Thrive Causemetics website that she had been searching for a mascara to love since she was 13. She finally found it with the Liquid Lash Extensions Tubing Mascara. It adds length and volume, and it’s easy to take off. The mascara comes off your lashes smoothly, leaving them clean and fresh. Cynthia recommends it to anyone who compliments her lashes, calling it the holy grail of mascara.

Sophie shared on the official Thrive Causemetics website that the tubing mascara has been her favorite for years. She often gets compliments on her lashes and enjoys recommending the product. She usually uses the shade Crystal, but was excited to try the Berry Brown color. The color shown in her photos is Berry Brown. She says it looks great, especially for redheads.

Legarda A. said, she is 57 years old and have never seen a mascara have such AMAZING results!!

Rochelle shared on the Thrive Causemetics website that she had been searching for a mascara that wouldn’t flake or leave black marks under her eyes. After her friend recommended Thrive, she tried it and was really happy with how long it lasts and how nice it looks.

Primelash mascara VS. Thrive mascara – Statistical data according to user reviews on primeprometics and thrivecausemetics

Conclusion

PrimeLash Mascara is tailored for mature women, it offers both volume and length with a formula that’s gentle on mature eyes. Its ease of application and removal makes it a convenient choice for daily use. Thrive Causemetics mascara is ideal for those seeking a lash extension effect without the salon visit. Its tubing technology ensures long-lasting wear and easy removal, though it requires careful application to avoid clumping. Both mascaras cater to different needs and preferences. If you prioritize volume and have sensitive eyes, PrimeLash may be the better choice. If you’re aiming for dramatic length and a lash extension look, Thrive Causemetics stands out.

Choose PrimeLash Mascara if you: If you’re looking for a gentle, nourishing mascara that gives soft volume, this is a great choice for mature, sensitive, or thinning lashes. It helps bring out your natural beauty and won’t cause irritation.

• Have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses.
• Prefer a natural, clump-free look with easy removal with gentle cleanser or Micellar water.
• Are seeking a mascara tailored for mature, thin, and sparse lashes.

Opt for Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara if you: You want long lashes, clean beauty ingredients, and a mascara that never smudges. This one works well for daily wear and keeps your look fresh, even on busy days.

• Desire a dramatic, lengthened lash appearance.
• Thrive mascara has more dramatic effects.
• Are comfortable with a tubing mascara that may require no effort to remove, easily remove with warm water.
• Value a formula enriched with lash-conditioning ingredients.