All recommended products on CosmeticsGears contain affiliate links. We are thankful to you for visiting our site, and we may earn a small affiliate commission when you buy through links on our website. These affiliate links will not impact the product price. This small commission will help us manage research expenses and review more makeup products. Thank you.

The Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes – Gentle Wear

Sensitive eyes usually get irritated with some mascaras on the market. People who have sensitive eyes feel uncomfortable with some environmental issues because their eyes are not as good as compared to normal eyes. This is why individuals with sensitive eyes avoid allergic environments, things, and dryness because of sensitivity issues.

Choosing a mascara is a sensitive part of face makeup products because it applies close to the eye area. Choosing the right mascara is also important for those with sensitive eyes, because if they do not care about the appropriate mascara product, it can be harmful.

So, it is right to say that every person who uses cosmetic products must choose ophthalmologist-tested, cruelty-free, and vegan mascara for sensitive eyes.

In this article, we will cover some essential factors, such as talking about sensitive eyes, suitable mascara for sensitive eyes, suggestions about the right or suitable mascara, and tips for healthy eyes (Ng & Evans, 2016). It’s all about taking care of sensitive eyes or looking great with the help of the right mascara.

Causes of sensitivity in the eye area: It is observed that many types of things can cause sensitivity of the eyes, as some health conditions based on dryness, allergies, and environmental problems also cause more proneness or irritation of the eyes.

Common symptoms experienced by those with sensitive eyes: Sensitive eyes have some symptoms which indicate that the eyes are sensitive because of abnormal feelings. It includes symptoms such as itching, watering, and a burning sensation.

How mascara can exacerbate sensitivity: If we talk about mascara and eye sensitivity, mascara is not a harmful product for the eyes. On the other hand, mascara can be harmful for those who have sensitive eyes. Before buying mascara, they must be curious about its formula and ingredients. If the mascara is not cruelty-free, vegan, or tested by an ophthalmologist, it may cause an allergy or worse condition for sensitive eyes. That’s why people who have sensitive eyes need to use clean mascara.

Ingredients that can hurt sensitive eyes: The mascara can irritate sensitive eyes because of specific ingredients such as formaldehyde, parabens, phenoloxyethanol, aluminum, coal tar dyes, propylene glycol, ethanolamine, fragrance, and retinyl acetate or retinyl palmitate.

Hypoallergenic formula is one of the great formulas for those people who have sensitive eyes, as it works for allergic reactions and makes your eyes safe. The hypoallergenic formula mascara is a medicated suggestion for sensitive eyes.

A fragrance-free product is also known as medicated mascara, which is harmless to the sensitive eye. Because of the fragrance, you must face some allergies and burning issues in the eye. That’s why people with sensitive eyes must avoid mascara that contains fragrance to reduce the risk of irritation and discomfort.

Gentle ingredients are suitable for sensitive eyes, such as aloe vera, chamomile, argan oil, and jojoba oil, which mainly consist of gentle and non-irritating ingredients. These ingredients helps to nourish the lashes and protect your sensitive eyes.

It is important for every product to be tested and approved by an ophthalmologist, because without any testing, cosmetic products can be harmful to sensitive areas of your skin. There is no doubt that skin is the most important part of our body. That’s why we suggested that every mascara that is tested and approved by an ophthalmologist can be gentle on extremely sensitive eyes.

Water-based mascara is better than oil-based mascara because the water-based formula is lighter and less likely to cause irritation. Whereas oil-based mascara can be difficult to remove before bed and can cause irritation for sensitive eyes, so you must use clean mascara for sensitive eyes.

Cabaret Lash-Lengthening Black Mascara, Vivienne Sabó

Price at time of publish: $12.56 at Amazon, $12.95 at viviennesaboparis, $28.75 at Walmart, $29.99 at eBay.

  • The secret to French beauty.
  • Clump-free and very lightweight.
  • 100% hassle-free and return policy.
  • It is also gluten-free, Vegan, Cruelty-free.
  • Classic French Mascara.
  • Not for daily use.

The Vivienne Sabo Cabaret Prime Mascara volumizes and defines lashes in just one coat. It is a lightweight and clump-free formula and does not flake or transfer. It’s easy to apply and remove using an eye makeup remover or cleansing balm. It is cruelty-free, long-lasting, and non-toxic.

Lash Next Door Waterproof Mascara

Price at time of publish: $18 at Amazon, $18 at lashnextdoor, $28.24 at ebay.

  • Clump-free and clean ingredients formula is safe for sensitive eyes.
  • Provides fuller and longer lashes.
  • No more raccoon eyes.
  • Takes two to three coats to get desired length and volume.

Lash Next Door Mascara can help you grow longer and fuller lashes. It contains safe ingredients and is gentle on sensitive eyes. The application is easy to apply and leaves your lashes looking flawless. It’s also smudge-proof. It is free of parabens and sulfates. It is excellent for everyday wear and can be easily washed off with a makeup remover or cleansing balm.


Price at time of publish: $11.40 at Amazon, $4.99 at Ulta, $4.99 at essencemakeup, $6.89 at Walmart.

  • Free from flaking and fading.
  • Vegan and Cruelty-free.
  • Free from alcohol.
  • Dramatic Lashes.
  • Waterproof Princess.
  • The top critical review by a customer is “Impossible to take off without a makeup remover”.

The essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect mascara is waterproof and gives your natural lashes a volumizing, false-lash effect. It doesn’t flake or fade and stays put all day. The brush is conical in shape and can be used individually to add definition to your lashes. This cruelty-free mascara adds maximum volume to thin lashes. You can easily remove the mascara using gentle makeup removers, micellar water, or cleansing balm.

Marcelle Ultimate Volume Waterproof Mascara

Price at time of publish: $15 at Amazon, $12.95 at marcelle, $34 at Walmart.

  • Fragrance-free and dermatologist tested.
  • Provides dramatics lashes with volumizing.
  • Hypoallergenic formula is best for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • The high-pigment formula.
  • One customer rated it three stars and said, “It doesn’t last long, though, and barely covers my lashes.”.

The Marcelle Ultimate Volume Mascara has a long-lasting, waterproof finish. The mascara makes lashes look thicker and fuller without clumping. This mascara comes with a special brush that applies the correct product. This brush can grab each lash and coat the mascara for an eye-opening effect.

Shahnaz Nazim

Shahnaz Nazim

The author, Shahnaz Nazim (Aleezay) is a mascara Enthusiast and Passionist. I do research for the best mascara products on the internet. Big websites like Amazon, byrdie, M.A.C. Cosmetics, Tarte, Maybelline, and Loreal Paris have honest ratings and reviews from customers who bought the products from these websites. I go there and read all the positive and negative reviews for each mascara product. I collect all the information about what people are talking about the product, for whom it is the best product, and for whom it is not good.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Cosmetics Gears